Four Lives is a compelling British true-crime drama that aired on BBC One in January 2022. Based on real-life events, it tells the tragic story of four young men who fell victim to serial killer Stephen Port, and the subsequent fight for justice led by their families against police negligence. The series, which has gained attention for its sensitive portrayal of the victims and their families, sheds light on both the human cost of the crimes and the systemic failings in the investigation process. Here’s an in-depth look at the show, its plot, cast, and the real-life case it is based on.

The True Story Behind Four Lives

Four Lives, initially titled The Barking Murders (distributed internationally), is based on the crimes committed by Stephen Port between 2014 and 2015. Over the course of several months, Port murdered four young men Anthony Walgate, Gabriel Kovari, Daniel Whitworth, and Jack Taylor by administering lethal doses of drugs. He then disposed of their bodies in and around Barking, East London.

Despite the disturbing similarities between the cases, including the geographic proximity of the deaths and Port’s known connection to some victims, the police failed to link the murders. It wasn’t until the families of the victims, led by their relentless investigations and determination, exposed the shortcomings of the police’s handling that the truth was uncovered. This real-life fight for justice forms the crux of the drama.

Plot Summary of Four Lives

The three-episode mini-series begins with the discovery of Anthony Walgate’s body, found near Stephen Port’s flat. Despite evidence that suggests foul play, the police initially treat Walgate’s death as a drug overdose. His mother, Sarah Sak, portrayed by Sheridan Smith, is unsatisfied with the police’s explanation and begins to push for further investigation.

As more bodies are discovered Gabriel Kovari and Daniel Whitworth the similarities in the deaths become impossible to ignore for the victims’ families, even though the authorities continue to dismiss their concerns. The show emphasizes the police’s failure to adequately investigate and connect the deaths, portraying their mishandling as gross negligence. The final episode depicts the discovery of Jack Taylor’s body and the eventual identification of Stephen Port as the killer, after Taylor’s sisters took matters into their own hands, compiling evidence that led to Port’s arrest.

Cast and Performances

The casting of Four Lives adds emotional depth to the retelling of these tragic events. Sheridan Smith delivers a powerful performance as Sarah Sak, Anthony Walgate’s mother, who leads the charge in seeking justice. Her portrayal is a tribute to Sarah’s tireless pursuit of truth, a journey marked by both grief and resilience.

Stephen Merchant’s portrayal of Stephen Port is another highlight. Known primarily for his comedic roles, Merchant’s chillingly understated performance as the callous serial killer is deeply unsettling. This casting choice emphasized the banality of evil, with Merchant portraying Port not as an overtly sinister figure, but as a disturbingly blank individual who blended into society while committing horrendous crimes.

The families of other victims are equally well-portrayed. Jaime Winstone plays Donna Taylor, one of Jack Taylor’s sisters, who, along with her family, refused to accept the police’s initial ruling of Jack’s death as an overdose. Their perseverance in collecting evidence on their own was key to Port’s eventual conviction.

Themes of Police Failures and Injustice

At its core, Four Lives is not just a crime drama but a damning critique of the systemic failures in policing, particularly in cases involving marginalized groups. The series highlights how the deaths of young, gay men were overlooked, with law enforcement showing an apparent lack of urgency in investigating the murders. The repeated dismissal of the families’ concerns is central to the story, showing how the victims were let down by the very institutions meant to protect them.

In reality, the Metropolitan Police later admitted to failings in the investigation and referred themselves to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC). The show underscores the importance of accountability and the role of families in pushing for justice when institutions fail.

Public and Critical Reception

Four Lives received critical acclaim for its sensitive handling of the real-life tragedy and the respectful portrayal of the victims. Many praised the series for focusing on the victims and their families rather than sensationalizing the crimes. Ed Cumming of The Independent highlighted how the show avoided melodrama, praising the script and direction for handling the sensitive material with care.

On the other hand, some critics felt that while the series effectively conveyed the emotional impact of the case, it could have delved deeper into the police’s accountability. Despite these minor critiques, Four Lives resonated with audiences, drawing attention to both the crimes and the institutional failings that compounded the tragedy.

Impact and Legacy

Beyond its role as a gripping drama, Four Lives has helped raise awareness about the failures of the police in handling the Stephen Port case. It sparked renewed conversations about police conduct in cases involving LGBTQ+ individuals and the broader issues of how marginalized communities are treated by law enforcement. For the families of the victims, the series serves as both a tribute to their loved ones and a public reckoning for the failures they had to endure.

FAQs

What is Four Lives? 

Four Lives is a British crime drama miniseries that aired in 2022. The show is based on the true story of the murders of four young men in East London between 2014 and 2015. It highlights the actions of serial killer Stephen Port and the subsequent investigations. The series is notable for shedding light on how police mishandled the cases due to systemic failings, especially related to LGBTQ+ communities.

Is Four Lives based on a true story? 

Yes, Four Lives is based on real events. It covers the true story of the victims of Stephen Port, who lured young men through online dating apps, drugged, and murdered them. The show is also focused on the families of the victims and their fight for justice.

How did the families of the victims react to Four Lives? 

The families of the victims were actively involved in the creation of the series and gave their approval. The show aims to give a voice to the victims’ families, highlighting their tireless efforts to bring attention to the mishandling of the investigation. Sheridan Smith’s portrayal of Sarah Sak, mother of Anthony Walgate, was particularly praised for her emotional depth.

Was the police involved criticized for their role in the investigation? 

Yes, one of the core themes of Four Lives is the criticism of the Metropolitan Police’s handling of the investigation. The families accused the police of not properly investigating the deaths, possibly due to prejudice against the victims being gay men. An inquest in 2021 later found that the police’s mishandling of evidence contributed to Port evading capture for longer than necessary.

Conclusion

Four Lives is more than a true-crime drama it is a powerful exploration of grief, injustice, and the relentless pursuit of truth. Through its sensitive portrayal of the victims and their families, the series ensures that the lives of Anthony Walgate, Gabriel Kovari, Daniel Whitworth, and Jack Taylor are remembered not just as victims of a horrific crime, but as individuals whose stories forced a reckoning with institutional failures.

For those interested in true crime, social justice, and gripping emotional storytelling, Four Lives is a must-watch series that offers both a heart-wrenching narrative and an important commentary on the intersection of crime and police accountability.

To read more, Click Here .